Congratulations to you, on your graduation from Meme-ing University and entrance into the greater void! The faculty and administration would also like to belatedly thank you for having enrolled, and compliment you on your refinement and sense of discrimination in choosing Meme-U … the only available choices (3).
Chapters
Rough guide, auto-generated from a transcript — times match the audio above.
For the full experience of exploring the series, go to officehours.syntopic.app.
0:00:00 Bob live — Marty Balin’s acid-trip song; Jean’s note on the 1981 Zappa club show; her Minneapolis bootlegger friend at First Avenue
0:02:42 NEW CALLER Matt Cohen — percept vs concept; his email to Cameron about their 11 Nov 2020 talk; Bacon’s Sylva Sylvarum via Whitehead
0:21:52 Matt’s Kuhnian “ordinary vs revolutionary perception”; Bohm and Krishnamurti; Bob: Carpenter on McLuhan’s 1966 MoMA talk
0:32:03 Matt reads Bohm (Wholeness and the Implicate Order) — perception as a “flash of understanding”; Bob drills him on who says what
0:45:06 Matt’s follow-up to Cameron — reading as guessing; McLuhan’s “tremendous shock” line; Cameron’s “forms, essences and grammars”
1:03:18 Cameron’s reply today — art as a “flash of understanding”, ordinary cognition, numbness; how Bacon’s dates and spellings vary
1:13:57 Bob previews the conceptual-art reading (Lior Lerman, Lucy Lippard, Adam Pugen); how Cameron blurs percept and concept
1:18:16 Matt: McLuhan’s letters to Harry Skornia as probes; the letter in Finnegans Wake; Innis vs McLuhan; Gombrich’s making and matching
1:26:38 Roll call — Alissa arrives, Chad listening, Clinton gone; Bob on whether to post the “two-hour preamble”
1:28:44 Art McKay asks who Cameron is; Chad: Resonant Interval needs no downloads; Matt’s download routine; two Dobbstown sites mixed up
1:36:58 Bob’s archive history — CKLN, Mae Brussell tapes, “before the Logos”, Ed Walker’s cassettes, Greg Duffell, Steve’s timeline, iON 2009
1:45:26 Alissa and Chad on Syntopic — “Googling for audio”, an Aldine Press for the spoken word, LLM bias, posting the Zappa index to Facebook
1:54:21 How Chad’s software works — vs ElevenLabs, named-entity recognition, a humanities focus; Alan Kay; “Festina Lente”; Alissa tours the site
2:08:16 Alissa rejoins by web call; Chad’s Venice and Ghent conferences — Gemini’s fake Krishnamurti quotes, the organizer, RAI
2:15:30 Bob: iON arranged it; Europe’s Gutenberg identity, “go out to be social”; the grants economy; Chad: legal depositions
2:23:59 Origin story — Karpathy’s LLM-wiki idea, Chad’s Obsidian iON notes, the first 10 Bob and Cameron episodes; knowledge graphs
2:31:28 Clinton: fission vs fusion (Hybrid Energies); Bob: “culture is our business”; Clinton’s SEO friend, Markdown, static sites, CDNs
2:42:06 Hegel and other subjects; linear vs semantic time; Clinton asks about diarization; sensitivity filter, opt-in pages for people
2:49:28 Ontology and relation types; Clinton: Bob and Cameron as an LLM stress test; symbolic and neuro-symbolic “trustworthy AI”
2:59:00 Clinton’s corpus callosum and “convoluted linearity”; Finnegans Wake vs choose-your-own-adventure; Cameron on why chronological
3:03:26 Alissa: mining an archive you haven’t heard (800 h of Mae Brussell); site analytics; tour of epistemic tags, Gladia, read-along transcripts
3:15:24 Archives of experts (Napoleon, German nuclear decommissioning), argument mining; Bob on dialogues 79–81, “flip into new hardware”
3:21:43 Setting up the Lippard reading; Brian asks about the 22 Nov Mae Brussell launch; Chad and Alissa sign off
3:27:57 READING: Lippard and Chandler, “The Dematerialization of Art” (1968), read by Clinton; shared by Lior Lerman to Culture Is Our Business
3:31:12 Bob’s preamble — CIA and the Congress for Cultural Freedom, art merging with commerce, advertising as the new art form
3:36:52 First sentence, “ultra-conceptual art” — Duchamp, WWI, abstract expressionism, Warhol’s Factory, Greenberg; Alissa names pop artists
3:56:12 Clinton: Kermode and occult anti-intellectualism; Bob: Lewis’s Time and Western Man, the “black bottom” of the 20s and “white bottom” of the 60s; Peggy Gale
4:05:05 The Arendt clip; the CIA and the literary magazines (the book “Finks”); New Age; Clinton: Rank, Becker, Curtis, the self as an art form
4:14:40 “The studio is again becoming a study” — artists as factory managers; Clinton: NATO’s 1968 software-engineering conference; roles as art
4:25:35 “Not enough to look at” — Michael Snow’s Wavelength; Schillinger’s five zones of art, which Bob maps onto media history; Christo
4:39:07 Clinton: why pick Schillinger? (Otto Rank); Bob: anthropology vs McLuhan’s larger ground; the narrowing to “the visual arts”
4:46:59 “Mathematical logic enters into art” — Macy Conferences, cybernetic sensing, Goodhart’s law and gamed metrics; Greta Thunberg
4:53:22 Minimalism retrieves nominalism; Clinton asks why Bob never uses hot and cool (8:47)
4:57:38 Abstraction — Locke, McLuhan’s two meanings of the word, the Greek alphabet; ideas as a reified substance; words as actions
5:07:44 Clinton calls the Matt segment “a write-off”; Explorations on McCarthyism; post-aesthetic “art about art”
5:12:04 Clinton on Lewis’s naïf vs faux-naïf; the Mellons and Bollingen; self-awareness and the collective consciousness; Harari on “culture”
5:25:04 Bob: Clinton and Chad grew up with computers; Brian and Clinton push back: “the computer is not a mass medium”
5:30:31 Utopianism and tabula rasa (Earth Day, Whole Earth); hyper-tactility and the void beneath sensation
5:37:06 “Nature is inherently beautiful” — Gell-Mann, Feynman, Christopher Alexander; E=mc² as sculpture; Brockman’s third culture
5:42:57 Clinton’s tweet against visualizing math; Bob on the new causes; the show’s new hyperlinked inventory
5:47:12 Clinton: Oxford Book of Literary Anecdotes — Leslie Stephen, Thomas Hardy, Kelvin’s vortex-ring atoms (1875)
5:59:04 Bob: the tetrad as a spiral; Clinton reads Claude’s explainer of Helmholtz vortex rings
6:04:28 Intermedia and John Cage; Take Today; entropy vs negentropy (Wylie Sypher)
6:13:04 “Order that incorporates disorder and chance” — Reinhardt, Kosuth; “the medium need not be the message”; Yoko Ono on McLuhan
6:19:44 Final paragraphs — art about criticism, Ortega y Gasset, Malevich’s white on white, “how much less nothing can be”
6:26:06 Wrap-up — Bob’s claim to be the top art critic; Clinton signs off; Mondo and Ruben; E=mc² as cliché; Clinton’s pipe anecdote (~10:27)
Listen LIVE! to the Office Hours weekly call-in show
Airs Wednesdays at 4:00pm EDT
